NATALIE BARR, HOST: The Coalition has slammed Labor’s $32,000 spend on a coffee cart at a global climate summit, despite the fact they introduced it. The Opposition called the expenditure galling amidst a cost-of-living crisis, but former leader and PM Malcolm Turnbull has defended it.
[Excerpt]
MALCOLM TURNBULL, FORMER PRIME MINISTER: For years now, the Australian pavilion has been delivering excellent Australian coffee, which gets lots and lots of people here. So, it is the most effective money spent on the marketing budget for this program here.
[End of excerpt]
BARR: Let’s bring in Health Minister Mark Butler and Deputy Opposition Leader Jane Hume. Good morning to you. Jane, we better start with you here. Angus Taylor was the Energy Minister when you guys brought in that coffee cart back in 2021. Why was the spending okay back then?
JANE HUME, DEPUTY OPPOSITION LEADER: I don’t remember in 2021 a coffee cart costing over $30,000, neither do I remember sending 200 bureaucrats at a cost of more than $2 million to COP at any point in time. Can I be honest, government is always about priorities and choices. This is the priority and the choice that Labor have made to spend taxpayer money on, at a time when we’ve got a cost-of-living crisis, at a time when emissions aren’t coming down, and when energy prices have gone up by 40 per cent, I would have much rather seen the $2 million, at least, that Labor has spent on attending COP, on going to COP, on sending 200 bureaucrats to COP, on restoring funding for the Ask Izzy program, which is essentially a portal for those that are in crisis, that are doing it tough in Australian now that would have directed them to things like domestic violence services or homeless services or food banks. And instead, for $2 million, that’s been cut. And yet we’re spending $2 million on a climate conference. I don’t think that the priorities and the choices of this government are serving Australian taxpayers well.
BARR: So, what would have been an appropriate spend for the coffee cart? Seeing as you guys started it.
HUME: I don’t remember what it would have cost to have served coffee, but I doubt that it was more than $30,000. That seems excessive. That seems performative.
BARR: It’s hard to criticise it now though, isn’t it, for you guys?
HUME: $30,000 on coffee, does that really serve a taxpayer these days when we’ve got a cost-of-living crisis?
BARR: Yeah, but if you brought in. You gave everyone the idea.
HUME: Not under a cost-of-living crisis, we certainly didn’t.
BARR: But it was after COVID, so we were spending left, right, and centre, I guess, in 2021.
HUME: Nat, we didn’t spend $30,000 on a coffee cart during a cost-of-living crisis. We didn’t send 200 bureaucrats at a cost of $2 million when we have energy bills going up by 40 per cent, and hundreds of thousands of Australians in energy hardship programs. This is crazy stuff.
BARR: OK. Mark, it’s not just the coffee. As Jane mentioned, 192 officials have apparently been flown over alongside the Minister, Chris Bowen, and the Prime Minister, Anthony Albanese. Yesterday, it was revealed there was $3 million spent on a documentary. How do you justify that?
MARK BUTLER, MINISTER FOR HEALTH AND AGEING, MINISTER FOR DISABILITY AND THE NDIS: Let's put the politics aside that Jane just prosecuted here. This is not just a government conference where governments negotiate with each other. For many years now, this has been one of the biggest industry and trade expos there is anywhere in the world. With vast numbers of businesses looking for places to invest and create jobs, looking for places to sell their products to consumers, and that is why governments, for years, of both political persuasions, have run these pavilions at this vast expo, wanting people to come and have a discussion with Australians about investment opportunities here. Now, governments, for a long time, have known that one of the best ways to bait the hook to get people to stop by the Australian pavilion is the fact we have the best coffee in the world. I mean, you won't see that in the British pavilion, unless they happen to have an Australian barista doing it, which I gather a lot of London cafes do nowadays.
BARR: Okay, fair enough.
BUTLER: You certainly wouldn't stop at an American pavilion for coffee. It works. It's worked for years, which is why we do it. This is an investment opportunity.
BARR: Fair enough.
BUTLER: Not a political opportunity for Jane.
HUME: How about you lower taxes? That's an investment opportunity.
BARR: Hang on a sec, Jane.
HUME: That means we all benefit, rather than just those that can afford to attend COP.
BARR: Wait a sec, Jane. Just a sec, Jane. So, Mark, let’s go back, 192 bureaucrats, do you honestly think that is a good spend? $3 million bucks for 192 people to go to that conference.
BUTLER: Look, as I said, this is now the biggest conference anywhere in the world. There are 90,000 registrants at this conference. Yes, 190 I've read are Australians. You know, some countries have two thousand people there. There are vast numbers at this conference doing government negotiations -
BARR: Yeah, OK, but let’s drill down on that. If that was your company, would you sit there and you'd go tick, tick, tick, all the airfares, all the accommodation, all the per diems. Is that a good expenditure right now?
BUTLER: It's a necessary expenditure.
HUME: No, it’s a choice.
BUTLER: This is the biggest industry trade expo there is in the world. It's not just a government negotiation, as important as that is. It's a huge opportunity for a country like Australia to talk to these vast numbers of businesses that are there looking for places to invest, and we want them to invest here in Australia. If they've got great new products, we want them to bring them here and sell them to our consumers as well.
BARR: Ok, well, Jane, last word because we do have to sell the country. I guess that's the flip side of this, and that's what the Government's saying. We can't just stay here and hope people come. That's the argument.
HUME: If you want to sell the country, how about you lower taxes? How about you make this a great place to start a business, to run a business, to grow a business, to restructure a business and to exit a business? And instead, you're raising taxes. Next week, you're going to raise taxes on small businesses. At the same time you're subsidising great big businesses who are over there swanning around at a climate conference. I don't think this Government has its priorities straight.
BARR: OK. We thank you both. We'll see you next week.
Media event date:
Date published:
Media type:
Transcript
Audience:
General public
Minister: